PJ Lobster House

Reviews about PJ Lobster House

• 3 / 5

  By Dom Caserma
  Used to love this place. Love the all you can eat shrimp. Last time I got sick and was in the bathroom 2 times while I was there. Not sure what the problem was. The cocktail sauce is literally red water. There is no reason to water down the cocktail sauce. It's supposed to be thick if you have to water down the sauce then there must be bigger problems or a lack of good staff. Although all of this we are willing to give another shot. Let's see if anything changes. That cocktail sauce really pissed me off
  May 20, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Steve K
  Been going there since back in the day when they were nothing more than a fishmonger with no restaurant. The seafood has always been top quality and staff has been, too. I miss it, having moved down south this past year, but it's worth taking a Greyhound and the LIRR for a great meal! My mother once drove us all the way from NJ just for the potato salad! Beats the pants off that overpriced tourist trap down Port by a country mile! I look forward to taking a trip back to LI so I can get some wonderful food!
  August 25, 2016